Disobedience virtue or vice analysis of erich fromms essay disobedience as a psychological and moral

It is the period of time where there is harmony among man and between man and nature. The fact that millions of people share the same vices does not make these vices virtues, the fact that they share so many errors does not make the errors to be truths, and the fact that millions of people share the same forms of mental pathology does not make these people sane.

He never said, "I have the right to be me. The stranger is precisely the person who is not part of my clan, my family, my nation; he is not part of the group to which I am narcissistically attached. More than ever in history the consolidation of our own product to an objective force above us, outgrowing our control, defeating our expectations, annihilating our calculations, is one of the main factors determining our development.

It is not a question of knowing what power is. A charming myth has risen about… History has recorded the role civil disobedience has played in many social reforms: The question is not really one of disobedience or obedience, but one of disobedience or obedience to what and to whom.

But like Hitler and the Jews, Stalin and anyone who opposed him, and in a milder fashion, the red-baiting in the U.

Full civil disobedience essay

Eventually, however, Fromm divorces rational thinking, self-liberation, and revolutionary action from all claims deriving from an authority other than the endogenous authority of the self itself see further Funk, The idea that we can build peace while encouraging the striving for possession and profit is mistaken.

That is the view acknowledged in the culture. Finally, whether with reference to the individual or the collective self, Fromm pays equal attention to the material efficacy of symbolic power and the symbolic efficacy of material power, as they associate with one another in the manner of a continuous dialectical becoming, also making central to such enquiry plentiful cases of explicit, physical violence.

Prometheus, in stealing the fire from the gods, lays the foundation for the evolution of man. That is to say, it, too, combines a political category, humanism, with a psychological one, the character structure, the latter constituting the basis for the former.

Their act of disobedience broke the primary bond with nature and made them individuals. It reduceds people to servants of the economy and of the machinery that their own hands build. Finally, he ends with Adolf Eichmann, who operated in the concentration camps.

But we cannot necessarily assume this. Considered a thinker of the neoanalytic tradition that included Harry Stack Sullivan, Karen Horney, and Clara Thompson, he brought cultural and historical factors within the purview of psychology and pointed out that much of what seemed instinctual human equipment is actually learned in a particular time and place.

Disobedience, then, in the sense in which we use it here, is an act of the affirmation of reason and will. In the bureaucratic system every person controls the one below him and is controlled by the one above. I can make no error, since it decides for me; I cannot be alone, because it watches over me; I cannot commit a sin, because it does not let me do so, and even if I do sin, the punishment is only the way of returning to the almighty power.

The humanistic conscience is founded on our instinct and the opinion of human race. People are also experienced as the embodiment of a quantitative exchange value.

To start with, the revolutionary character is fearless of power.

Erich Fromm | Obedience as a psychological and moral problem

While less vile than pure sadists, the bureaucrats are more dangerous, because in them there is not even a conflict between conscience and duty; their conscience is doing their duty; human beings as objects of empathy and compassion do not exist for them.

The Courage to be Human. The more he gets out of him the more satisfied he is. By a general act of will freedom of thought has been put out of function, because many give up thinking as free individuals, and are guided by the collective to which they belong.

New York, Evanston, and London: The second standard objection says, If the law is to be effective - outside the anarchists utopia - there must be some machinery for detecting and penalizing lawbreakers.

What are we, then, to make of the fact that deadly confrontations most usually occur between neighbouring communities or groups Blok, ? Dynamically, however, they are of a different nature. The giant corporations which control the economic, and to a large degree the political, destiny of the country constitute the very opposite of the democratic process; they represent power without control by those submitted to it.

My obedience makes me part of the power I worship, and hence I feel strong. God killed both of them Leviticus Normative humanism is based on the idea that there are satisfactoryh and unsatisfactoryd solutions to the problem of human existence. As long as everybody wants to have more, there must be formations of classes, there must be class war, and in global terms, there must be international war.

Credibility strikes to be an important part of this claim. If the individual fails in a profitable investment of himself, he feels that he is a failure; if he succeeds, he is a success.

In the benign form, the object of narcissistic attachment is focused on achievement, or, more precisely, on the effort so made by private individuals or groups. Nuova serie di Dei delitti e delle pene. Thoreau stated this best… Violent Civil Disobedience In this article John Morreall discusses the act of civil disobedience.

The word conscience is used to express two phenomena which are quite distinct from each other.FOR CENTURIES kings, priests, feudal lords, industrial bosses and parents have insisted that obedience is a virtue and that disobedience is a vice.

OVERVIEW: Erich Fromm was one of the two twentieth-century psychologists, along with the Gestalt psychologist Kurt Lewin, who most explcitly applied their psychological ideas to an analysis of society.

Others who did so, but not in such a thoroughgoing manner, included Abraham Maslow, Carl Rogers, and. The Erich is one of the most popular assignments among students' documents. If you are stuck with writing or missing ideas, scroll down and find inspiration in the best samples. Erich is quite a rare and popular topic for writing an essay, but it certainly is in our database.

They each write essays giving their educated opinion about a certain situation. Erich Fromm first published the essay "Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem" in It was also published in the textbook Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum. Civil Disobedience Essay Examples | Kibin An Analysis of of Thoreaus Perspectives in His Duty of Civil Disobedience Disobedience: Virtue or Vice - Analysis of Erich Fromms Essay.

was Mahatma Gandhi, because of his complete identification with the people of IndiasThese questions, and many more, are further observed by psychoanalytical historian Erich Fromm in his literary essay "Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem". In this essay, Fromm argues that it is because an act of disobedience that human history began and it is unlikely that human civilization will be terminated by an act of obedience/5(5).

Disobedience virtue or vice analysis of erich fromms essay disobedience as a psychological and moral
Rated 5/5 based on 81 review